If School Strategy Promises Impact, Why Do We Measure Performance?
6 min read
By Stuart Robinson
When shareholders invest in a business, they expect to understand the return generated by their investment. Dividends, capital appreciation, and shareholder returns provide evidence of whether the business has delivered financial value.
Schools operate differently. Their purpose isn't to generate financial returns for shareholders, although sustainability remains important. Yet families entrust them with something arguably more valuable than investment capital: years of their children's education and development.
Parents, particularly those paying substantial fees, inevitably form their own assessment of that investment. They may never describe it as ROI, but their expectations are no less real.
And schools make some significant promises about what that education will deliver.
Read almost any independent school's mission, values, or graduate profile, and you'll encounter aspirations to develop confident, compassionate, resilient, curious, and capable young people.
Which raises a question I think school leaders and directors should be asking more frequently.
If our strategy promises to make a difference in students' lives, why do we measure its success through indicators that tell us comparatively little about that difference?
The Uncomfortable Difference Between Performance and Impact
I've written previously about why schools should measure performance, particularly the importance of connecting strategic objectives to meaningful measures.
I remain convinced that performance measurement is essential. Without it, strategic plans risk becoming elaborate collections of good intentions, occasionally consulted and rarely held accountable.
However, there's a distinction deserving greater attention: performance tells us what has been achieved, while impact asks what difference those achievements have made.
ATARs, VCE/HSC completion rates, university offers, and academic awards provide legitimate evidence of student achievement. But do they demonstrate the impact the school has made?
Imagine two students graduating from different schools. One achieves an ATAR of 99.5, having entered secondary school with exceptional academic ability and considerable family support. Another achieves an ATAR of 75, having entered with significant learning challenges and little confidence in their abilities.
Which school made the greater difference?
We simply cannot tell from those results.
The second student may have experienced extraordinary development, while the first may have achieved their result with comparatively little additional contribution from the school. Equally, the first student's school may have made an enormous difference.
The ATAR doesn't establish either conclusion.
This isn't an argument against academic achievement. It's an argument against confusing achievement with educational impact.
A school's results tell us where students finished. Its impact measures should help explain how far they travelled and what contribution the school made to that journey.
What Healthcare Understands About Impact
My thinking was prompted by a fascinating Harvard Business Review article by Robert Kaplan and Constance Spitzer, A Better Way to Measure Social Impact.
The authors explore how organisations frequently measure the resources committed and activities delivered, rather than the outcomes experienced by those they're supposed to benefit.
Drawing on healthcare, they reference one surgeon's observation:
"Only patients experience their outcomes, so only patients can report on them."
I found myself wondering why we don't apply this principle more deliberately in schools.
We can report how many students participated in leadership programs, attended outdoor education camps, or completed service activities. We can measure attendance, participation, and satisfaction.
But none necessarily establishes whether students became better leaders, more resilient individuals, or more compassionate members of society.
We've measured the activity without necessarily measuring its impact.
There's also a challenging possibility that we may be congratulating ourselves on delivering experiences that students don't believe made much difference.
Student voice is hardly novel in education. Yet there's an important distinction between asking students whether they enjoyed an experience and whether it changed them.
The first assesses delivery. The second begins to assess impact.
Students aren't always objective judges of their development, so their reflections should be considered alongside demonstrated capabilities and evidence of growth. Nevertheless, surely those experiencing the education deserve a substantial voice in evaluating its outcomes.
The Graduate Profile: A Strategic Promise, Not a Decorative Statement
This brings me to one of the most underutilised strategic instruments in schools: the graduate profile.
Schools invest considerable energy articulating the characteristics they want their graduates to possess. These profiles often express the school's educational philosophy more clearly than its strategic plan.
But what evidence would convince us they've delivered those aspirations?
If independent thinking is central to the graduate profile, how does the school assess its development? If compassion is a defining characteristic, what behaviours demonstrate it? If resilience is promised, how does the school distinguish development from characteristics students already possessed?
These questions aren't as impossible to answer as we might imagine.
The University of Melbourne's Melbourne Metrics initiative explores ways of assessing complex capabilities that traditional academic measures struggle to capture.
Its work includes capabilities such as agency, ethical action, collaboration, and quality thinking, supported by developmental progressions and evidence of learning.
It demonstrates that qualities often considered too abstract to measure can be assessed more systematically, without pretending human development can be reduced to a perfectly precise number.
For me, the strategic implications are substantial.
A graduate profile shouldn't exist independently of the school's strategic objectives. It should help define the outcomes the strategy promises to deliver.
A school promising independent thinkers should make deliberate choices about curriculum, pedagogy, and learning experiences that support independent thinking, then gather evidence that those choices are working.
Otherwise, the graduate profile risks becoming an exceptionally polished description of students the school hopes to produce.
A graduate profile without evidence of its achievement is closer to a marketing promise than a measure of educational success.
Thirteen Years of Education. Where Is the Impact Statement?
There's something curious about how we evaluate the completion of education.
A typical undergraduate university degree takes three or four years. Universities assess whether students have acquired the knowledge and capabilities required for their qualifications, awarding degrees when those standards are met.
Yet a school may have thirteen years to influence a young person's intellectual, social, emotional, ethical, and personal development.
Thirteen formative years during which identities develop, relationships form, and capabilities emerge.
And we frequently conclude that undertaking with academic results, a graduation ceremony, and a heartfelt speech about the wonderful people our students have become.
But where is the evidence of the broader educational impact we promised?
Research offers some interesting possibilities.
The Gallup Alumni Survey explores university graduates' employment, wellbeing, and perceptions of their education. Australia's Longitudinal Surveys of Australian Youth similarly examine how young people navigate education, employment, and adulthood.
Neither provides a ready-made school impact measure, but both demonstrate the value of listening to graduates and examining outcomes beyond academic qualifications.
I don't believe schools should be held accountable for graduates' careers, relationships, or personal circumstances years after they leave. Too many subsequent influences lie beyond their control.
The school's principal accountability should be for the impact it was positioned to deliver by graduation.
Alumni research can help test whether that preparation proved useful, but the essential question should already have been answered by the time students left.
Did the school develop the capabilities, character, knowledge, and dispositions it promised?
We celebrate students leaving school, then often stop measuring the very outcomes we spent thirteen years promising to develop.
If Impact Is the Measure, Strategy Must Deliver the Evidence
I don't underestimate the complexity of measuring educational impact.
Students arrive with different abilities, circumstances, and aspirations. Families, communities, and experiences outside school all contribute to their development.
We cannot isolate every influence or claim responsibility for every desirable characteristic a graduate possesses.
But acknowledging these complexities shouldn't be an excuse to avoid accountability for the contributions schools can reasonably make.
Indeed, the more significant a school's claims about developing young people, the greater its responsibility to demonstrate how those claims are being fulfilled.
This is where impact measurement becomes a strategic responsibility rather than another task for the curriculum team.
A school's mission and graduate profile should establish the difference it intends to make. Its strategy should identify the choices necessary to achieve that difference. Its educational programs should translate those choices into experiences that develop the intended capabilities.
And its measurement framework should establish whether those capabilities are developing.
That means gathering evidence throughout a student's education, rather than attempting to reconstruct thirteen years of development in the final weeks of Year 12.
For directors, it also changes the nature of strategic accountability.
Rather than asking exclusively whether initiatives have been completed, budgets maintained, enrolment targets achieved, or examination results improved, boards should ask for evidence that the strategy is making the intended difference for students.
These aren't competing responsibilities. Financial sustainability, operational effectiveness, and academic achievement remain essential. But they cannot substitute for understanding the impact of the education being delivered.
A school might complete every strategic initiative, meet every implementation deadline, and receive glowing reports about its programs. Yet if those activities haven't produced the intended educational difference, can we reasonably declare its strategy successful?
I would suggest not.
Ultimately, a school's strategy should be judged not simply by what the organisation accomplishes, but by the changes it brings about for its students.
We've become remarkably sophisticated at measuring performance. The opportunity now is to become equally disciplined about demonstrating impact.
After all, if our mission describes the difference we promise to make, shouldn't our strategy be accountable for delivering it?
Stuart Robinson
Founder Stuart Robinson brings 25+ years in school business management. With an MBA (Leadership), Bachelor of Business, and AICD graduate credentials, he's highly experienced in helping schools set strategic direction.
Related Posts

If School Strategy Promises Impact, Why Do We Measure Performance?

NCCD Funding: How Boards Can Find Assurance Before the Audit

When Growing Enrolments Become a Strategic Warning Sign

The Fear of Strategic Stagnation | When School Strategy Stops Moving
